Introduction
It contains a massive collection of 664 reports and sayings from the khalq af 39-al al-ibad english pdf
Look for the Muhsin Khan translation because it provides brackets clarifying the theological point. Alternatively, seek the “Sunnah Publishing” or “TROID” editions of the English translation of Khalq Af’al al-‘Ibad as a standalone 40-60 page booklet. Search: “Sahih al Bukhari Volume 9 (Darussalam) PDF”
In the 3rd Islamic century, the Mu‘tazilah school gained state patronage under the Abbasid Caliph al-Ma’mun. They argued that humans are the independent creators (khaliq) of their own actions. Their logic: if Allah created both belief and disbelief, how could He punish disbelief? Given the difficulty in pinpointing the exact document
Given the difficulty in pinpointing the exact document or paper you're referring to, I'll offer a few suggestions on how to proceed:
The work is a collection of 664 reports containing Hadiths and sayings of the Salaf (early scholars). Its primary focuses include: Salafi Bookstore UK Createdness of Human Actions
The work is structured as a collection of narrations and scholarly commentary: